I am Brian Wilson with Ben Greenman

 

I am Brian Wilson with Ben Greenman



 I am hesitant to recommend this book at any price. It made me feel odd. I had the feeling I was reading the statement from a POW written by his captors. 


The Brian Wilson book “ I am . . . Brian Wilson” made me feel oddly uncomfortable. Never have I had a feeling like that while reading a book. It’s difficult to explain except to say that I don’t think these are the words of Brian Wilson.


There was something fishy about this book. It almost felt as though many of the words were forced upon Brian. I dunno. It almost seems as if that was Brian’s life and Brian’s music through the filter of another person. But what do I know?


I have no idea of the truth. I simply accept the book as it sits in front of me and as it sits I have to say no steer clear and maybe look for a good biography somewhere. 


I felt so odd I wanted to quit halfway through but I  stuck with it and by the end, I wasn’t happy. I truly wish I had another book about Brian to read instead of this one. Yet this is all I have and I’m not a fan.


A rock and roll autobiography or biography should never make you feel so odd you just can’t fully explain it. I would say avoid this unless you happen to be completing a Brian Wilson library.


It's a perfectly passable passel of papers nothing more.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Backstage Passes: Life on the Wild Side with David Bowie By Angela Bowie

Image
Backstage Passes: Life on the Wild Side with David Bowie  By Angela Bowie and Patrick Carr I was looking forward to reading Backstage Passes but, oh my. Angela Bowie seems angry. The anger I felt coming through in this book overshadowed pretty much everything else. There was this whole undertone of anger. Why is Ms. Bowie angry? She had some of the best things in life. She is rich, famous, beautiful, and had a famous husband but is still angry.  Truth is I finally think I understand why she is angry. Understanding why Angela Bowie is angry is not the same as agreeing with why she is angry. It wouldn’t be so bad if she had tried to contain her anger to a chapter or two but well . . . the anger is everything.  There were many, many things about David Bowie I could have hoped to have learned. There are many things I could have hoped to have learned about the relationship between the two.  I could have learned more about how she has inspired a tune or two of his - like “...
Read more
Image
  Roger Daltry The Biography   Tim Ewbank and Stafford Hildred When I finish a book I am often left with a general impression of a book.  It could be anything really. An impression of how the band began or what conditions were like when they were poor. Anything number of things.  This book left me asking one seemingly simple question: Why? Why? Why did the authors, editors, and whoever allow this nonsense to be released? Why? Oh my, this is not good. I like to leave books behind and try to move on to the next book cold. I couldn’t do that in this case. The problem is I just finished reading what might be the single best biography of a popular artist ever written. And then I picked up this book for a read. What a mistake. Maybe if I had left this for a few weeks and then went on to this book. Well, now that I think about it that would not have changed anything. Waiting a few weeks would have simply delayed the inevitable. The book is filled with inaccuracies and slopp...
Read more

“Willie Nelson: An Epic Life” by Joe Nick Patoski

Image
   “Willie Nelson: An Epic Life” by Joe Nick Patoski  Willie, a country artist, just reeks of rock and roll and, well, marijuana if we’re being honest. Willie certainly has a rock and roll attitude and has lived a rock and roll life.  “Willie Nelson: An Epic Life” got off to a slow, boring start. I don’t care who you are, I don’t need to read a biography that explains not only your origins but the origins of your family in the United States. Did we really need to learn about Uncle Peck?? I’m sure he was a swell guy but Uncle Peck does not belong. Oh, I forgot good old Prilly!! I really wanted to like this book. I was hoping that its size would mean a depth comparable with that of a couple of Rolling Stones autobiographies. In the end, I thought the depth was much more filler than anything substantial about the man. Filler. It was annoying to find so much fluff and filler.  Well, no that’s not entirely fair. There is a good examination of how Willie’s tax battles...
Read more